I was saddened and dismayed at the ongoing strife between Isreal & Palestine. With Isreal currently indulging in their raids of the Gaza strip with no end in mind, my heart sank.
Further to this, I feel that there is no motion from the international community in assisting the peaceful resolution. Beyond the Swiss government accusing Isreal of breaking humanitarian law by inflicting "collective punishment" on Palestinians, that is. Who else is advocating for Palestinians right to return to Palestine? Wasn't this right extended to Jewish settlers back in the day?
Here are some facts:
1948 the modern state of Isreal was formed. Needless to say, the placement of the state of Isreal was formed on a land that had two seperate histories, one for Jews and one for Palestinians.
As a result of the state of Isreal being formed we found nearly 700,000 Palestinians were turned into refugees. Also, since the creation of Isreal the state has devoted much of their resources into defence, preparing for the inevitable attacks from a displaced people.
Yes, there is reason to be optimistic. For the 6 decades that Isreal has existed, it has only been recently when talks of peace and resolution have taken a greater precidence over the extermination of the Palestinian people. So we can be greatful for that, correct?
Now further to this, I wish to look at numbers. As it is the number of deaths that we can paint another picture. These numbers are a little out of date, but, since this time, there has not been a significant shift in figures. I just couldn't locate the other source to cite immediately, I'll change the blog as I come across more information.
Israel is responsible for some 733 Palestinian noncombatant deaths, while Palestinians have killed 546 Israeli noncombatants.
If we look at the ages of those killed, there is a relatively even distribution over the ages for the Isreali noncombatant deaths. Whereas, if we look at Palestinian noncombatant deaths, they are concentrated mostly between the ages of 10-13 year old boys.
60% of noncombattant Palestinians killed are men between the ages of 12-29 with only 20% of Isreali deaths falling in this age range.
Why the lopsided numbers? There could be a lot of reasons, numbers are only only just that and they paint another side to the story. If you want more check this site out
Now I'm not looking to demonize anyone! I realize that too is part of the fear in approaching this conflict! It is one that has heel and toe dipped in religion, and in face of a population that was victim to strife in the earlier part of the century by Europe, many are hesitant to speak out for fear of being perceived as Anti-Semetic. There are also many articles found online that attest to this, including some that proclaim that Anti-Semetism exists still in European politics in face of the Arab-Isreal conflict! I truly cannot see how, the international community isn't exactly doing anything for either side, they simply are looking the other way! So how is that helping either side?
Regardless, at the end of the day, we need to understand that we have a desperate people and a fearful people. The desperate feel that they have nothing more to lose, and the fearful are scared about what the desperate may do.
Tuesday, July 04, 2006
Newsflash: Lopsided Slaughter
Posted by
KarmaCake
7/04/2006 06:09:00 PM
- KarmaCake 7:05 PM
-
A little piece of enlightenment and balance. That's what you get here!
Thanks, Susan for adding another dimension. Hopefully, it'll help us all understand the conflict a little better.
xoxo
2
comments:
@karmacakedotca
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(341)
-
▼
July
(51)
- Stop Hating on Kelis!
- Karmacake: Faster then the Associated Press
- movie review: miami vice
- ADVENTURE IN INTERNET DATING PART 2
- Weekend Roundup: July 28-30, 2006
- random lines from a variety of songs.
- Zanta Update
- Sex Sex Sex!
- Sex advice from 90's tv stars
- Local Yokel - Toronto Zanta - YES! YES!
- Poo Flags for Bush
- Roundup: Busy Weekend!
- Can you believe I'm such a spaz
- Celeb Gossip: Britney has lost her marbles.
- It's True. Trudeau left a comment on myspace!
- Girlfriends are awesome friends.
- The Master of the Universe or the Princess of Powe...
- Canada's Next Top Model
- HAPPY BIRTHDAY ALERT!
- I Got Flashed! Again!
- Bounce if You Agree! Heck Bounce if You Don't!
- Operanation 2006 is Coming!
- Spontaneous Public Art
- No Panty Hose For You!
- Spreading The Word of Good Fashions Sometimes Make...
- Music: Hot Hot Hot!
- Are We Living Sex and the City?
- It's a Scorcher!
- Thought of the Day: Weddings & Funerals
- Mr. T Will Pitty You Fool! So BE SOMEBODY!
- Fun With the Girls!
- Prez Bush Should Just Stop Talking!
- Shannon Doherty Ending Relationship One Episode at...
- Tax Cut Insanity
- Sirens outside my door
- Horoscopes Can Sometimes Be True.
- REDECORATION!
- Who is on Lavalife?
- Weekend Update
- Tribute to Fabulousness: Liza Minnelli
- Karmami: Congrats Travis!
- Live From A Small Room
- Hottest New Tracks for the Summer! Listen Now!
- Trudeau Now on Myspace?!?
- No More WEMF for Karmacake
- Photos: Joel's Private Party Aboard the Hellish Ca...
- Can You Really Put Your Trust in Fate?
- Toronto Clubs: Level, Suite & Republik
- Newsflash: Lopsided Slaughter
- Happy Fourth ofJuly
- Fear & Loathing at 942
-
▼
July
(51)
A few comments (and there are always bound to be comments when you tackle the Arab-Israeli conflict!):
- In 1948, 10 Arab countries tossed out almost one million Jews. How do you think these nations would react to the notion of a Jewish right of return? Iran? Iraq? Lebanon? Qatar? As a Jew, I cannot even visit most of these countries, much less resume residency/reclaim stolen property/
etc.
- I see a lot of parallels between the Palestinian situation and that of First Nations people in Canada. I bet if you did a bit of research, you'd find that the land that your condo was built on was once part of a First Nation's traditional territory. Like the Palestinians, First Nations have been subjected to massacres/
persecution/humilitation. Does that mean that you're going to give your condo back? Probably not. Why? Because of realities on the ground. While the First Nations situation was (and continues to be) a huge black mark on Canada's name, the world has moved on. It is simply not realistic to move everyone out of downtown Toronto, even if this is the truly just thing to do. Canada is thus looking for alternate ways of addressing the wrongs committed against urban aboriginals. By the same token, a Palestinian right of return is the objectively just thing to do. However, it is simply not realistic to expect Israel to relocate hundreds of thousands, maybe even millions of individuals, not to mention infrastructure. All of this is not to say, however, that Palestianians should not be compensated for what has been taken from them.
- Keep in mind that Palestinians have continued to fire Qassams at Israel post-disengagement. Two have landed in Ashkelon, a major city, in the last few days. The Al-Aqsa brigade also claims to have chemical and biological weapons in its possession. Israel is pretty worried about this situation -- seems to be underpinning the current Gaza campaign (not that I'm trying to justify this in any way shape or form!).
- It's interesting that you perceive the international community to be biased towards Israel. Most Israelis perceive international media/organization to be heavily pro-Palestian. An example -- did you know that the new UN Human Rights body has "Israeli human rights offences in the Palestian territories" as a standing discussion item at all meetings? Absolutely nothing about other paragons of human rights -- Syria, China, Zimbabwe, Kazakhstan, Sri Lanka, etc. to name a few.
My point is that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a truly complex situation. For every offense committed by the Palestinians (and vice-versa), the Palestinians can point to an equally grave offense that has been committed by the Israelis (and vice-versa). Tit-for-tat is why the situation in the Middle East is going nowhere good.